http://www.boston.com/news/nation/washington/articles/2010/01/03/romney_will_hit_key_primary_states_on_book_tour/
They just announced that Mitt Romney is launching a book tour. Guess where he’s going to flack the book and speak out? Iowa.
So, to the shock of nobody, he’s running again in 2012.
Romney is no mere dabbler in Mormonism. He used a ministerial deferment to dodge the draft, spent two and a half years as a Mormon missionary, and got his bachelor’s at Brigham Young.
So, Mormonism.
Joseph Smith, founder of Mormonism, came from quite humble beginnings, born to farmers in a New York community that dabbled in mysticism, visions, and folk magic. The folk magic included a semi-mystical New England practice known as “treasure-digging”, sometimes using magic stones to hunt for treasure and lost items. One of these adventures, an alleged gold expedition, led to Smith’s conviction for fraud. At the ripe old age of 18 he was allegedly visited by an angel named, swear to God, Moroni. The angel allegedly led Smith to a site where ancient Egyptians, who had somehow wandered into upstate New York (wrong turn at Albuquerque?), had buried the Book of Mormon conveniently near Smith’s house.
The “sacred” texts were carved on metal plates in “reformed Egyptian”, a language unknown outside the world of the Mormons, but known somehow to Smith, despite the fact that he was a young farmer with no education, who of course had never been on the same side of the planet as Egypt. Smith convinced someone to write down the “Books of Mormon” as Smith dictated them from the “magic plates” hidden on the other side a blanket, like Clark Gable in “It Happened One Night”; the scribe was warned that if he tried to see the magic plates he would be struck dead. At other times Smith claimed he was reading the texts using magic glasses, or by looking at magic stones inside his hat. Then the plates were “magically” assumed into heaven. Thus, the “holy” book of Mormon was given to the world.
On the strength of this book, the Mormons insist that the church established by Jesus, Christianity, has fallen into spiritual chaos, changing Jesus’ laws and teachings, and following doctrines that are wrong, as Paul had allegedly foretold; as a result, God considers the modern Christian churches to be an abomination. The Mormons claim they are the ones who have restored Christianity to its proper form. Thus, the Mormon view of Christians.
Smith claimed that blacks, African-Americans, were descended from creatures who had refused to take a side in the battle between god and Lucifer; Smith referred to blacks as cursed and inferior. Brigham Young believed that blacks were lacking in intelligence, and that anyone who had sex with an African-American would die on the spot. Until 1978 the Mormons banned black men from the clergy.
Mormons also believe that native Americans are actually part of the lost tribes of Israel (I’m thinking BYU is a little shaky on anthropology and geography). They oppose gay marriage and equal rights for women.
Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts
Sunday, 3 January 2010
Wednesday, 4 November 2009
Christianity plagiarized the Christ story
Here is more proof that the entire fundament of Christianity is a fraud.
Christianity cannot stand up as a philosophical belief unless the story of Christ’s life – birth, ministry, death, resurrection, role as savior – also stands up factually.
There is little dispute that he lived, preached in Jerusalem , threw a fit in the Temple , and was executed for it. But all of the other stuff was fiction: it was plagiarized from the Egypt myth-makers.
The Egyptian god Horus existed centuries before Christ. Horus was the only begotten son of God, born of the virgin Isis-Meri and Seb, of royal descent; his birth was announced by an angel, heralded by a star, witnessed by shepherds and celebrated thereafter in December. Herut tried to murder him but God told his mother to flee. His life story is a blank from age 12 to 30, whereupon he is baptized in a river by a prophet who was beheaded, and resists temptation in the desert. He probably had 12 disciples, delivered a sermon on a hill, cared for the hungry, healed the blind and sick, walked on water, and raised al-Asar from the dead. He was probably crucified with two thieves, descended into hell, and his resurrection, after three days, was announced by women. He was regarded as a god and savior of humanity, the shepherd and the fisher of men.
So not only is the central myth of the New Testament a fiction, it is flagrantly plagiarized fiction. They didn’t even concoct their own myths, they stole someone else’s.
And unless the mission and divinity of Christ are based in fact, Christian belief falls apart.
Christianity cannot stand up as a philosophical belief unless the story of Christ’s life – birth, ministry, death, resurrection, role as savior – also stands up factually.
There is little dispute that he lived, preached in Jerusalem , threw a fit in the Temple , and was executed for it. But all of the other stuff was fiction: it was plagiarized from the Egypt myth-makers.
The Egyptian god Horus existed centuries before Christ. Horus was the only begotten son of God, born of the virgin Isis-Meri and Seb, of royal descent; his birth was announced by an angel, heralded by a star, witnessed by shepherds and celebrated thereafter in December. Herut tried to murder him but God told his mother to flee. His life story is a blank from age 12 to 30, whereupon he is baptized in a river by a prophet who was beheaded, and resists temptation in the desert. He probably had 12 disciples, delivered a sermon on a hill, cared for the hungry, healed the blind and sick, walked on water, and raised al-Asar from the dead. He was probably crucified with two thieves, descended into hell, and his resurrection, after three days, was announced by women. He was regarded as a god and savior of humanity, the shepherd and the fisher of men.
So not only is the central myth of the New Testament a fiction, it is flagrantly plagiarized fiction. They didn’t even concoct their own myths, they stole someone else’s.
And unless the mission and divinity of Christ are based in fact, Christian belief falls apart.
Saturday, 26 September 2009
America's "no religion" community is growing explosively
In 1992, upon learning that Bil Clinton would be the Democratic presidential nominee, the Republicans decided they would go after him with the "family values" strategy, and they've been trying to sell that strategy ever since.
In 1992 the number of Americans who say they have no religion was about 8 percent.
Now, after 20 years of rightwing efforts to ram their views down our throats on abortion, school vouchers, school prayer, intelligent design, putting the Commandments in courtrooms, stem cell research, euthanasia, cloning, civil unions, HPV shots, contraception, sex education, faith-based initiatives, banning books, assisted suicide...the "no religion" sector has doubled to 15 percent. The fastest growing religion is...no religion.
Another Republican success.
In 1992 the number of Americans who say they have no religion was about 8 percent.
Now, after 20 years of rightwing efforts to ram their views down our throats on abortion, school vouchers, school prayer, intelligent design, putting the Commandments in courtrooms, stem cell research, euthanasia, cloning, civil unions, HPV shots, contraception, sex education, faith-based initiatives, banning books, assisted suicide...the "no religion" sector has doubled to 15 percent. The fastest growing religion is...no religion.
Another Republican success.
Tuesday, 14 July 2009
Newly discovered Bible proves it was man's work
Time magazine reports that the "new" old Bible they found shows that the Bible was subjected to at least 27,000 human corrections. So much for the infallible word of God.
http://www.time.com/time/specials/packages/completelist/0,29569,1910141,00.html
Erasures, additions, corrections, substitutions — Sinaiticus reveals a Bible-in-process. Between the 4th and 12th centuries, various scribes changed earlier colleagues' bad spelling. Of more theological significance, the Gospel of Mark ends early. Sinaiticus even contains two books that didn't make the later canon cut, the Epistle of Apostle Barnabas and the Shepherd of Hermas. The changes are significant, according to British Library curator Scot McKendrick, because "the recognition is that Scripture, as it comes down to us, is transmitted by human hand."
The three manuscript powerhouses behind the modern Bible are Sinaiticus, Vaticanus and Alexandrinus. Like Sinaiticus, the Vaticanus codex dates to the 4th century, with Alexandrinus transcribed 100 years later. Vaticanus was preserved and overwritten in the 15th century. Alexandrinus may be the best preserved. But only Sinaiticus has the prized complete New Testament. The books' different ordering, contents and appearances again testify to the Bible's evolutionary history.
http://www.time.com/time/specials/packages/completelist/0,29569,1910141,00.html
Erasures, additions, corrections, substitutions — Sinaiticus reveals a Bible-in-process. Between the 4th and 12th centuries, various scribes changed earlier colleagues' bad spelling. Of more theological significance, the Gospel of Mark ends early. Sinaiticus even contains two books that didn't make the later canon cut, the Epistle of Apostle Barnabas and the Shepherd of Hermas. The changes are significant, according to British Library curator Scot McKendrick, because "the recognition is that Scripture, as it comes down to us, is transmitted by human hand."
The three manuscript powerhouses behind the modern Bible are Sinaiticus, Vaticanus and Alexandrinus. Like Sinaiticus, the Vaticanus codex dates to the 4th century, with Alexandrinus transcribed 100 years later. Vaticanus was preserved and overwritten in the 15th century. Alexandrinus may be the best preserved. But only Sinaiticus has the prized complete New Testament. The books' different ordering, contents and appearances again testify to the Bible's evolutionary history.
Friday, 8 May 2009
Saint Paul, founder of capitalism?
Who was the really remarkable character in the Bible?
If we strip all of the miracles and other nonsense out of the Bible, we find that the Israelites first appeared in the Fertile Crescent, were captured and enslaved by the Egyptians, escaped, committed genocide and ethnic cleansing in the Holy Land, built the Kingdom of Israel, established laws which Moses claimed came straight from God, split into two kingdoms, and then were conquered by the Assyrians, the Babylonians and the Romans. So Moses’ main achievements were creating the fiction of a very angry and cruel deity, a preposterous list of religious and dietary laws, and a nation which distinguished itself chiefly in genocide, ethnic cleansing, and the unlucky habit of being conquered over and over by their neighbours. History has plenty of leaders like him – not terribly remarkable. He did launch the rather destructive notion of monotheism as a concept, but other than that...
Joshua? Poster boy for genocide. Go read the book named after him. An unremarkable leader – the pages of history are filled with bloodthirsty mass murderers just like him.
How about Mary, venerated throughout the Catholic world? A rather clumsy peasant girl managed to get pregnant, as peasant girls have been doing for thousands of years. She claimed that she was still a virgin, and that the child inside her was actually...God, implanted by the Holy Spirit (the “Holy Spirit” was probably that cute shepherd over in the next valley). This story is so dubious that Matthew and Luke tell it two completely different ways. So the whole story of Jesus, and indeed all of Christianity, got started because of a pregnant teenager, one of the oldest, most unremarkable stories in human history.
How about Jesus? In a culture where men get married and take up a trade as teenagers, Jesus did neither, possibly due to his illegitimate status. He wandered around the Galilee for a couple of years, telling sweet Aesop-like stories to farmers and fishermen. His philosophy of brotherhood was quite noble, but Greek and eastern philosophers had been preaching many of the same concepts for at least 300 years. Jesus went to the holiest site in the entire Jewish world, the temple in Jerusalem, and went nuts and trashed the place. The local authorities, already suspicious of messianic preachers, did the inevitable: they executed him. So, Jesus...a profoundly good, moral man. But in and of himself, not really remarkable.
Saint Peter? An unimaginative leader who died for his faith like hundreds of other Christians of the Roman era. And his whole team was not too bright – they didn’t start setting up a church because they thought Jesus was coming back immediately. Unremarkable.
The really remarkable figure in all this? Saint Paul. Originally a bitter opponent of Christianity, he was open-minded enough to embrace totally new ideas. He crafted Christianity into a message that could be spread across the Roman Empire. He persuaded the original Jewish leaders of the sect that they would need to let go of Jewish law if they were going to sell the new creed successfully – it would be impossible to win new adherents if their first decree to potential converts was to chop off their peepees. He travelled across the Empire repeatedly, selling the message, making the Church grow and grow, and managing for many years to avoid being executed by either the local pagans or the local Jews. He supplemented that effort with letters, exhorting followers to stay on message and spread the word. He refereed personal and philosophical conflicts, building a Church strong enough to thrive and grow in a sometimes hostile environment, and refining the original teachings into a sturdy doctrine. He converted Christianity from a tiny sub-sect of the already tiny sect, Judaism, into a faith which blew away ten centuries of Greco-Roman paganism and conquered an Empire, and then a continent. By the time Paul was done, he had laid the groundwork for a global enterprise which would survive many challenges (including Luther, Henry VIII, Galileo and Darwin) and remain powerful and profitable for almost 2000 years.
Profitable for two millennia.
Name a CEO who ever accomplished anything of the kind. Who comes close? The Krupps? The Rothchilds? The East India Company? Rockefeller? Lloyds? Dupont? The Bank of America? Hearst? Lehman Brothers (LOL!)? Carnegie?
Saint Paul, founder of capitalism. Not Adam Smith, not Ricardo, not Ayn Rand, not Henry Ford.
You would think that the rightwingers would have latched onto this guy, who perfectly united their two favourite things, Christianity and capitalist-style enterprise. But, ya know, a lot of these guys don’t actually read the Bible. Too busy with the World Nut Daily, Breitbart, Fox....
If we strip all of the miracles and other nonsense out of the Bible, we find that the Israelites first appeared in the Fertile Crescent, were captured and enslaved by the Egyptians, escaped, committed genocide and ethnic cleansing in the Holy Land, built the Kingdom of Israel, established laws which Moses claimed came straight from God, split into two kingdoms, and then were conquered by the Assyrians, the Babylonians and the Romans. So Moses’ main achievements were creating the fiction of a very angry and cruel deity, a preposterous list of religious and dietary laws, and a nation which distinguished itself chiefly in genocide, ethnic cleansing, and the unlucky habit of being conquered over and over by their neighbours. History has plenty of leaders like him – not terribly remarkable. He did launch the rather destructive notion of monotheism as a concept, but other than that...
Joshua? Poster boy for genocide. Go read the book named after him. An unremarkable leader – the pages of history are filled with bloodthirsty mass murderers just like him.
How about Mary, venerated throughout the Catholic world? A rather clumsy peasant girl managed to get pregnant, as peasant girls have been doing for thousands of years. She claimed that she was still a virgin, and that the child inside her was actually...God, implanted by the Holy Spirit (the “Holy Spirit” was probably that cute shepherd over in the next valley). This story is so dubious that Matthew and Luke tell it two completely different ways. So the whole story of Jesus, and indeed all of Christianity, got started because of a pregnant teenager, one of the oldest, most unremarkable stories in human history.
How about Jesus? In a culture where men get married and take up a trade as teenagers, Jesus did neither, possibly due to his illegitimate status. He wandered around the Galilee for a couple of years, telling sweet Aesop-like stories to farmers and fishermen. His philosophy of brotherhood was quite noble, but Greek and eastern philosophers had been preaching many of the same concepts for at least 300 years. Jesus went to the holiest site in the entire Jewish world, the temple in Jerusalem, and went nuts and trashed the place. The local authorities, already suspicious of messianic preachers, did the inevitable: they executed him. So, Jesus...a profoundly good, moral man. But in and of himself, not really remarkable.
Saint Peter? An unimaginative leader who died for his faith like hundreds of other Christians of the Roman era. And his whole team was not too bright – they didn’t start setting up a church because they thought Jesus was coming back immediately. Unremarkable.
The really remarkable figure in all this? Saint Paul. Originally a bitter opponent of Christianity, he was open-minded enough to embrace totally new ideas. He crafted Christianity into a message that could be spread across the Roman Empire. He persuaded the original Jewish leaders of the sect that they would need to let go of Jewish law if they were going to sell the new creed successfully – it would be impossible to win new adherents if their first decree to potential converts was to chop off their peepees. He travelled across the Empire repeatedly, selling the message, making the Church grow and grow, and managing for many years to avoid being executed by either the local pagans or the local Jews. He supplemented that effort with letters, exhorting followers to stay on message and spread the word. He refereed personal and philosophical conflicts, building a Church strong enough to thrive and grow in a sometimes hostile environment, and refining the original teachings into a sturdy doctrine. He converted Christianity from a tiny sub-sect of the already tiny sect, Judaism, into a faith which blew away ten centuries of Greco-Roman paganism and conquered an Empire, and then a continent. By the time Paul was done, he had laid the groundwork for a global enterprise which would survive many challenges (including Luther, Henry VIII, Galileo and Darwin) and remain powerful and profitable for almost 2000 years.
Profitable for two millennia.
Name a CEO who ever accomplished anything of the kind. Who comes close? The Krupps? The Rothchilds? The East India Company? Rockefeller? Lloyds? Dupont? The Bank of America? Hearst? Lehman Brothers (LOL!)? Carnegie?
Saint Paul, founder of capitalism. Not Adam Smith, not Ricardo, not Ayn Rand, not Henry Ford.
You would think that the rightwingers would have latched onto this guy, who perfectly united their two favourite things, Christianity and capitalist-style enterprise. But, ya know, a lot of these guys don’t actually read the Bible. Too busy with the World Nut Daily, Breitbart, Fox....
Wednesday, 6 May 2009
Swine flu, another gift from our "loving God"
“God loves you!”
Does he, now?
Only a particularly pusillanimous people could stick with a god as cruel as Jehovah.
No God could claim to be loving and merciful, and then give us mosquitos, flies, cockroaches, fleas, locusts, ants, bedbugs and boll weevils. And of course rats.
And the viruses for influenza, HIV, polio, foot and mouth, cervical cancer, chickenpox, herpes, Ebola, bird flu, smallpox, hepatitis, yellow fever, dengue, measles, rabies, meningitis and Reye syndrome.
And the bacteria for tuberculosis, bubonic plague, cholera, salmonella, typhus, diphtheria, syphilis, leprosy, anthrax, tetanus, botulism and Chlamydia.
And the potato famine spore, Multiple sclerosis and ALS.
And congenital defects.
And lymphomas, sarcomas, melanomas, carcinomas, leukemias and blastomas.
And floods, droughts, earthquakes, hurricanes, typhoons, fires, avalanches, volcanic eruptions and blizzards.
And now the swine flu, which ironically has struck hardest in the one of the most religiously devout nations in earth.
No God who loved mankind would work so hard, to kill so many millions of innocent people, in so many cruel ways. Incidentally, 9 million children under five died last year, and another 9-10 million will die this year. Because God loves the little chillun so much. And their parents.
Thus demonstrating that the loving God of the Bible is either a liar, or a lie.
If you look at Genesis 2 and 3, “Our Loving God” planted two special trees in Eden: the tree of life, and the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. God warned Adam against eating from the tree of knowledge, because if Adam and Eve ate from that tree, they would be “as gods”. God said nothing about the tree of life. Eve saw that the tree of knowledge would make her wise; and when Adam and Eve ate the fruit they did become wise. God was horrified: in Genesis 3:22-24 he thundered that Adam had become like God and the angels, and he had to be thrown out of Eden so that he wouldn’t also eat from the tree of life. So he expelled Adam and installed cherubim to guard the tree of life.
Some argue that God was terrified that Adam would become as wise and powerful as God and the angels were. He saw his greatest creation....as a threat to “Him”. He condemned all mankind, for all time, to toil, pain and death....due to his own fear.
But if God was afraid of that happening, he didn’t need to plant either of those trees – he could have kept knowledge and eternal life all to himself, since he was omnipotent. Jehovah wanted Man to fail the test, so that God would remain superior, and in control. Planting the tree of knowledge, and then instilling an incredible thirst for knowledge in man, was simply tempting man on purpose, knowing he would fail the test and leave God in charge. An exercise in ego.
Of course this Genesis story was a myth concocted by a priest, to prove that men were sinful and inferior, and in need of constant guidance (for a fee) from God’s self-appointed representative, the priest. What a racket.
The Bible tells that Our Loving God pulled the same trick at Babel. Men built a tower which looked close to touching heaven, so God punished them, just because he felt the men were being uppity.
Moving on... Our Loving God demands the unconditional love of Abraham, insists he kill his own child as proof of his love, and changes his mind at the last minute. Jehovah later allows Jephtha to sacrifice his daughter to prove his devotion to God.
Jehovah demands that Moses take on the impossible task of building the nation of Israel out of a bunch of slaves. Moses achieves the impossible, over decades of backbreaking work. Then, fed up by 50 years of abuse from Jehovah, he has one moment of doubt. One moment in which his faith – not even his love – of God wavered just a bit. And for that, Jehovah banned him from the very country he created.
(And what he did to the Egyptians! Plague of locusts, famine, killing all the children….We’re going to make that our holy day in the spring – celebrating all those dead Egyptian babies!)
Look at this guy Noah! I’ll force him to do some impossible stuff, like he’s pledging the world’s worst fraternity – build a boat the size of a football field, and fill it with every animal in the world! And for a finale, I will kill every man, woman and child on earth, because they didn’t love me enough. Look at all the water!
Then I’ll wipe out Sodom and Gomorrah for dessert.
Speaking of obedience, how about Job? Jehovah takes his most obedient servant and destroys his whole life, on a bar bet with Satan. Like the Duke brothers in "Trading Places", ruining their own nephew's life on a one-dollar bet. And when Job has the nerve to complain, Jehovah says "I'm God and you're not, so screw you. -- And I still expect you to worship me next Saturday." Such are the wages of obedience. What's the point, if you get screwed anyway?
As with God, so it is with his anointed leaders. Joshua is a whole book about how he launched a campaign of genocide and ethnic cleansing upon all the Holy Land, killing man, woman and child, except the virgins, save them for the soldiers! He undoubtedly got the idea from Moses in Numbers 31 – kill everyone including the children, but save the virgins for the party! Kings and Chronicles continue the story of endless war, murder and treachery. In 2 Kings, children are torn apart by bear and their heads are thrown in baskets (ch. 10); pregnant women are sliced open (ch. 15).
Oh, let’s see. Psalms 137, dashing children against stones; Zechariah 13, kill your child if he even mentions another religion; dead children throughout 2 Kings, cannibalism in both Jeremiah and Ezekiel; 2 Samuel, God creates a three-year famine because the wrong people were massacred. And through the centuries ...priests terrorizing all of Europe with inquisitions and executions and excommunication, with horror stories about children going to limbo, with incredibly dangerous and counterproductive claims such as the assertion that condoms don’t really work. An earthquake kills a thousand men, women and children, and the priest smirks at the weeping survivors and says “see, it’s all because you didn’t love God enough, and you didn’t listen to me.”
But in the first book of Samuel (1 Samuel 15), there’s a new twist. In that book, God commands Saul to commit genocide against the Amalekites, and slaughter all the men, women and children. Saul does commit genocide, but he fails to kill one Amalekite fast enough to suit God, and also saves some of the Amalekite animals, so they can offer them as a sacrifice, to show their love for God. And for those reasons alone, God rejects Saul. Later, Saul is having trouble on the battlefield, and Samuel rises from the dead to tell Saul, again, that because of his failure to slaughter the Amalekites completely on command, Saul himself is condemned. Soon after, Saul’s army is attacked and he is killed. God condemned Saul for not committing genocide with sufficient brutality (1 Samuel 28). So, to win God's love, it's not enough to be a mass murderer. You must be a perfectly efficient mass murderer.
So, God loves us, huh...? Well, "His" book is one massive orgy of cruelty.
Does he, now?
Only a particularly pusillanimous people could stick with a god as cruel as Jehovah.
No God could claim to be loving and merciful, and then give us mosquitos, flies, cockroaches, fleas, locusts, ants, bedbugs and boll weevils. And of course rats.
And the viruses for influenza, HIV, polio, foot and mouth, cervical cancer, chickenpox, herpes, Ebola, bird flu, smallpox, hepatitis, yellow fever, dengue, measles, rabies, meningitis and Reye syndrome.
And the bacteria for tuberculosis, bubonic plague, cholera, salmonella, typhus, diphtheria, syphilis, leprosy, anthrax, tetanus, botulism and Chlamydia.
And the potato famine spore, Multiple sclerosis and ALS.
And congenital defects.
And lymphomas, sarcomas, melanomas, carcinomas, leukemias and blastomas.
And floods, droughts, earthquakes, hurricanes, typhoons, fires, avalanches, volcanic eruptions and blizzards.
And now the swine flu, which ironically has struck hardest in the one of the most religiously devout nations in earth.
No God who loved mankind would work so hard, to kill so many millions of innocent people, in so many cruel ways. Incidentally, 9 million children under five died last year, and another 9-10 million will die this year. Because God loves the little chillun so much. And their parents.
Thus demonstrating that the loving God of the Bible is either a liar, or a lie.
If you look at Genesis 2 and 3, “Our Loving God” planted two special trees in Eden: the tree of life, and the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. God warned Adam against eating from the tree of knowledge, because if Adam and Eve ate from that tree, they would be “as gods”. God said nothing about the tree of life. Eve saw that the tree of knowledge would make her wise; and when Adam and Eve ate the fruit they did become wise. God was horrified: in Genesis 3:22-24 he thundered that Adam had become like God and the angels, and he had to be thrown out of Eden so that he wouldn’t also eat from the tree of life. So he expelled Adam and installed cherubim to guard the tree of life.
Some argue that God was terrified that Adam would become as wise and powerful as God and the angels were. He saw his greatest creation....as a threat to “Him”. He condemned all mankind, for all time, to toil, pain and death....due to his own fear.
But if God was afraid of that happening, he didn’t need to plant either of those trees – he could have kept knowledge and eternal life all to himself, since he was omnipotent. Jehovah wanted Man to fail the test, so that God would remain superior, and in control. Planting the tree of knowledge, and then instilling an incredible thirst for knowledge in man, was simply tempting man on purpose, knowing he would fail the test and leave God in charge. An exercise in ego.
Of course this Genesis story was a myth concocted by a priest, to prove that men were sinful and inferior, and in need of constant guidance (for a fee) from God’s self-appointed representative, the priest. What a racket.
The Bible tells that Our Loving God pulled the same trick at Babel. Men built a tower which looked close to touching heaven, so God punished them, just because he felt the men were being uppity.
Moving on... Our Loving God demands the unconditional love of Abraham, insists he kill his own child as proof of his love, and changes his mind at the last minute. Jehovah later allows Jephtha to sacrifice his daughter to prove his devotion to God.
Jehovah demands that Moses take on the impossible task of building the nation of Israel out of a bunch of slaves. Moses achieves the impossible, over decades of backbreaking work. Then, fed up by 50 years of abuse from Jehovah, he has one moment of doubt. One moment in which his faith – not even his love – of God wavered just a bit. And for that, Jehovah banned him from the very country he created.
(And what he did to the Egyptians! Plague of locusts, famine, killing all the children….We’re going to make that our holy day in the spring – celebrating all those dead Egyptian babies!)
Look at this guy Noah! I’ll force him to do some impossible stuff, like he’s pledging the world’s worst fraternity – build a boat the size of a football field, and fill it with every animal in the world! And for a finale, I will kill every man, woman and child on earth, because they didn’t love me enough. Look at all the water!
Then I’ll wipe out Sodom and Gomorrah for dessert.
Speaking of obedience, how about Job? Jehovah takes his most obedient servant and destroys his whole life, on a bar bet with Satan. Like the Duke brothers in "Trading Places", ruining their own nephew's life on a one-dollar bet. And when Job has the nerve to complain, Jehovah says "I'm God and you're not, so screw you. -- And I still expect you to worship me next Saturday." Such are the wages of obedience. What's the point, if you get screwed anyway?
As with God, so it is with his anointed leaders. Joshua is a whole book about how he launched a campaign of genocide and ethnic cleansing upon all the Holy Land, killing man, woman and child, except the virgins, save them for the soldiers! He undoubtedly got the idea from Moses in Numbers 31 – kill everyone including the children, but save the virgins for the party! Kings and Chronicles continue the story of endless war, murder and treachery. In 2 Kings, children are torn apart by bear and their heads are thrown in baskets (ch. 10); pregnant women are sliced open (ch. 15).
Oh, let’s see. Psalms 137, dashing children against stones; Zechariah 13, kill your child if he even mentions another religion; dead children throughout 2 Kings, cannibalism in both Jeremiah and Ezekiel; 2 Samuel, God creates a three-year famine because the wrong people were massacred. And through the centuries ...priests terrorizing all of Europe with inquisitions and executions and excommunication, with horror stories about children going to limbo, with incredibly dangerous and counterproductive claims such as the assertion that condoms don’t really work. An earthquake kills a thousand men, women and children, and the priest smirks at the weeping survivors and says “see, it’s all because you didn’t love God enough, and you didn’t listen to me.”
But in the first book of Samuel (1 Samuel 15), there’s a new twist. In that book, God commands Saul to commit genocide against the Amalekites, and slaughter all the men, women and children. Saul does commit genocide, but he fails to kill one Amalekite fast enough to suit God, and also saves some of the Amalekite animals, so they can offer them as a sacrifice, to show their love for God. And for those reasons alone, God rejects Saul. Later, Saul is having trouble on the battlefield, and Samuel rises from the dead to tell Saul, again, that because of his failure to slaughter the Amalekites completely on command, Saul himself is condemned. Soon after, Saul’s army is attacked and he is killed. God condemned Saul for not committing genocide with sufficient brutality (1 Samuel 28). So, to win God's love, it's not enough to be a mass murderer. You must be a perfectly efficient mass murderer.
So, God loves us, huh...? Well, "His" book is one massive orgy of cruelty.
Immorality and the Bible
A newspaper here in London reported today that a professor of forensic medicine reviewed the Bible from the point of view of sexual crimes and deviant behavior, and found date rape, voyeurism, exhibitionism, necrophilia, adultery, incest, sexual harassment, drug facilitated sexual assault, rape, gang rape, homosexuality, transvestism, and bestiality.
Actually, for some time I've been puzzled: how is the Bible supposed to be a moral guide?
There are people who insist that the Bible is the only book you need, as a guide for morality. Well, I’m no expert, but the more I read the Bible, the more I get the impression that the Bible is too immoral to expose to children, and organized religion itself is child abuse.
In addition to the many cruelties in the Old Testament, we have the bedroom escapades of Solomon, Esther and Ruth, the polygamy of Abraham, Jacob, David and Solomon, the pornography of Song of Songs.... Abraham gave the Pharaoh his wife to sleep with so as to save his own life; Lot offered his daughters to be raped by strangers, so they wouldn’t bother him; his daughters later got him drunk, slept with him, and got pregnant. In Judges 19, a priest gave his concubine to a gang which raped her until she died; he then cut up her body. Is this the Word of God, or Law And Order SVU?
The message of the New Testament is also a bundle of joy: God allegedly insists that even the most innocent of us are insignificant sinners who should cringe before him; he pretends he is improving mankind by murdering Jesus, but he is really just killing his own son because he can’t revenge himself upon mankind any other way, having experimented with mass extermination many times already. What moral lesson am I supposed to derive from that?
And of course the narcotic, hallucinatory nonsense of the Book of Revelation.
Once you get half a dozen books into the Bible, God is exposed as an immoral mass murderer who loathes the human race because we don’t love him enough, and can scarcely get through a chapter of the Bible without trying to murder or torment a man, a city, a country or all of mankind. Sounds to me as though the God of the Bible is all about destroying life, not creating it.
Scarcely an election goes by without at least one politician implying that he is morally upright because he follows the Bible. One would think that a leader who followed the Bible and swore his oath of office on the Bible would do as they did in the Bible -- genocide, ethnic cleansing, slavery, senseless cruelty, rape, infanticide, intolerance, racism, pornography, masturbation, abortion, incest, the death penalty prescribed for offenses that are minor or just plain silly....Any leader who was repellent enough to use the Bible as his moral guide would end up ruling like Caligula or Robert Mugabe.
So does church attendance make people more, then? Apparently not. Surprisingly, evangelical Christianity does not lead to moral behavior: the red states with more religious folks have 76 percent of the most dangerous cities, all of the top states for burglary rates, almost all the top states for theft and murder.
It truly is possible to live and teach a child morality without a Bible in your hand – in fact it’s easier that way. A study run in the University of Virginia proves that morality is actually innate in humans due to evolution – as man evolved and began forming primitive societies, human development fostered behaviours which improve the smooth functioning of the community, i.e. moral and ethical behaviour. And religion had nothing to do with it. In fact religion allows the immoral to pretend superior morality, substituting belief and ritual for real virtue.
I find it bizarre that priests who preach, but don't practice, celibacy, demand the right to lecture the rest of us on what morality is, and what "unnatural sex" is. Celibacy is the most unnatural form of sexual preference there is. So there’s another puzzle right there.
And that's before we even get to their antediluvian attitudes to marriage, divorce, contraception and a woman's right to choose. As though you want advice on love and marriage from the one guy in town who knows nothing about either one. Like having a blind man drive you to the airport.
And then the priests go back to their church, their "housekeepers" and their "altar boys", and the wine and the candles and the incense. Isn’t it odd that the more modern society takes a good hard look at these religious people, with all the investigative power of the media and the internet, the creepier they look? Even beyond the rampant pedophilia in the Catholic church – unsurprising when you put the sexually repressed in control of the totally vulnerable -- there is the epidemic of financial crimes by churches and preachers, the sexual escapades, Jimmy Swaggart, Jim Bakker...
Incidentally, people who behave in a moral way only because of belief in God are not showing morality, just obedience based on fear. Only freely-chosen morality is the real thing, right?
And as I see the way parents, teachers and priests teach religion to children, I’m coming to the conclusion that Christianity is child abuse. Evangelicals, in particular, read their kids the horror stories of the Bible -- the Israelites committing genocide in the book of Joshua, Jehovah constantly killing or threatening to kill individual people or even all mankind -- and then terrorize children with fairy tales about spending eternity in hellfire. They inculcate a fear and hatred of new ideas. They teach kids never to question authority -- never to think, to decide for themselves.
And how can any parent tell their child that God killed his own son for no apparent reason?
They fill their heads with lies, superstition and stupidity. They want science out of the schools -- and prayer into the schools. They tell kids that observable scientific fact -- global warming, evolution -- is just plain wrong; why don't they stop medical schools from teaching anatomy and physiology because it proves that the virgin birth is impossible? Imagine what butchers our doctors would be.
Evangelicals, like the Nazis, target children deliberately, selling a dangerous product to vulnerable minds, like crack dealers. Children have a right to be protected from such abuse, don’t you think?
Kids should never be taught hate or ignorance. If kids were taught to think and question, instead of hating, there would be no suicide bombers.
And then they insist that one of the most dangerous things for children -- sex -- is the one thing they should never have explained to them, so they can be safe. Protecting children from the dangers of the world is admirable, but protecting them from knowledge of the dangers of the world is indeed child abuse.
If a cult brainwashed and abused children the way our established religions have, the police would be at the door lickety-split. Wouldn’t they?
Note: I've also heard good things about Ben Akerley's "X-Rated Bible".
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleURL&_udi=B8CY1-4TRHCD9-1&_user=10&_rdoc=1&_fmt=&_orig=search&_sort=d&view=c&_acct=C000050221&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=10&md5=05a8a7bd7ea91986730c6a752bcf8fa9
http://www.metro.co.uk/news/article.html?Why_the_Bible_isnt_such_a_Good_Book&in_article_id=646644&in_page_id=34
Actually, for some time I've been puzzled: how is the Bible supposed to be a moral guide?
There are people who insist that the Bible is the only book you need, as a guide for morality. Well, I’m no expert, but the more I read the Bible, the more I get the impression that the Bible is too immoral to expose to children, and organized religion itself is child abuse.
In addition to the many cruelties in the Old Testament, we have the bedroom escapades of Solomon, Esther and Ruth, the polygamy of Abraham, Jacob, David and Solomon, the pornography of Song of Songs.... Abraham gave the Pharaoh his wife to sleep with so as to save his own life; Lot offered his daughters to be raped by strangers, so they wouldn’t bother him; his daughters later got him drunk, slept with him, and got pregnant. In Judges 19, a priest gave his concubine to a gang which raped her until she died; he then cut up her body. Is this the Word of God, or Law And Order SVU?
The message of the New Testament is also a bundle of joy: God allegedly insists that even the most innocent of us are insignificant sinners who should cringe before him; he pretends he is improving mankind by murdering Jesus, but he is really just killing his own son because he can’t revenge himself upon mankind any other way, having experimented with mass extermination many times already. What moral lesson am I supposed to derive from that?
And of course the narcotic, hallucinatory nonsense of the Book of Revelation.
Once you get half a dozen books into the Bible, God is exposed as an immoral mass murderer who loathes the human race because we don’t love him enough, and can scarcely get through a chapter of the Bible without trying to murder or torment a man, a city, a country or all of mankind. Sounds to me as though the God of the Bible is all about destroying life, not creating it.
Scarcely an election goes by without at least one politician implying that he is morally upright because he follows the Bible. One would think that a leader who followed the Bible and swore his oath of office on the Bible would do as they did in the Bible -- genocide, ethnic cleansing, slavery, senseless cruelty, rape, infanticide, intolerance, racism, pornography, masturbation, abortion, incest, the death penalty prescribed for offenses that are minor or just plain silly....Any leader who was repellent enough to use the Bible as his moral guide would end up ruling like Caligula or Robert Mugabe.
So does church attendance make people more, then? Apparently not. Surprisingly, evangelical Christianity does not lead to moral behavior: the red states with more religious folks have 76 percent of the most dangerous cities, all of the top states for burglary rates, almost all the top states for theft and murder.
It truly is possible to live and teach a child morality without a Bible in your hand – in fact it’s easier that way. A study run in the University of Virginia proves that morality is actually innate in humans due to evolution – as man evolved and began forming primitive societies, human development fostered behaviours which improve the smooth functioning of the community, i.e. moral and ethical behaviour. And religion had nothing to do with it. In fact religion allows the immoral to pretend superior morality, substituting belief and ritual for real virtue.
I find it bizarre that priests who preach, but don't practice, celibacy, demand the right to lecture the rest of us on what morality is, and what "unnatural sex" is. Celibacy is the most unnatural form of sexual preference there is. So there’s another puzzle right there.
And that's before we even get to their antediluvian attitudes to marriage, divorce, contraception and a woman's right to choose. As though you want advice on love and marriage from the one guy in town who knows nothing about either one. Like having a blind man drive you to the airport.
And then the priests go back to their church, their "housekeepers" and their "altar boys", and the wine and the candles and the incense. Isn’t it odd that the more modern society takes a good hard look at these religious people, with all the investigative power of the media and the internet, the creepier they look? Even beyond the rampant pedophilia in the Catholic church – unsurprising when you put the sexually repressed in control of the totally vulnerable -- there is the epidemic of financial crimes by churches and preachers, the sexual escapades, Jimmy Swaggart, Jim Bakker...
Incidentally, people who behave in a moral way only because of belief in God are not showing morality, just obedience based on fear. Only freely-chosen morality is the real thing, right?
And as I see the way parents, teachers and priests teach religion to children, I’m coming to the conclusion that Christianity is child abuse. Evangelicals, in particular, read their kids the horror stories of the Bible -- the Israelites committing genocide in the book of Joshua, Jehovah constantly killing or threatening to kill individual people or even all mankind -- and then terrorize children with fairy tales about spending eternity in hellfire. They inculcate a fear and hatred of new ideas. They teach kids never to question authority -- never to think, to decide for themselves.
And how can any parent tell their child that God killed his own son for no apparent reason?
They fill their heads with lies, superstition and stupidity. They want science out of the schools -- and prayer into the schools. They tell kids that observable scientific fact -- global warming, evolution -- is just plain wrong; why don't they stop medical schools from teaching anatomy and physiology because it proves that the virgin birth is impossible? Imagine what butchers our doctors would be.
Evangelicals, like the Nazis, target children deliberately, selling a dangerous product to vulnerable minds, like crack dealers. Children have a right to be protected from such abuse, don’t you think?
Kids should never be taught hate or ignorance. If kids were taught to think and question, instead of hating, there would be no suicide bombers.
And then they insist that one of the most dangerous things for children -- sex -- is the one thing they should never have explained to them, so they can be safe. Protecting children from the dangers of the world is admirable, but protecting them from knowledge of the dangers of the world is indeed child abuse.
If a cult brainwashed and abused children the way our established religions have, the police would be at the door lickety-split. Wouldn’t they?
Note: I've also heard good things about Ben Akerley's "X-Rated Bible".
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleURL&_udi=B8CY1-4TRHCD9-1&_user=10&_rdoc=1&_fmt=&_orig=search&_sort=d&view=c&_acct=C000050221&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=10&md5=05a8a7bd7ea91986730c6a752bcf8fa9
http://www.metro.co.uk/news/article.html?Why_the_Bible_isnt_such_a_Good_Book&in_article_id=646644&in_page_id=34
Monday, 27 April 2009
Another word for religious faith: gullibility
No God could give us the divine faculty of reason, and then hide himself so that we could not comprehend him unless we set reason aside in favour of faith. He would not hide behind mysteries, and miracles are the lies of men, not the word of God. By the same token, if there is a God, the cosmos would be one of his greatest works, and he definitely would want us to admire and marvel at it. But the Church acting in his name didn’t even want us to look. The Church knew Man would get smarter and ask annoying questions. So from the very beginning, the priests stressed that faith was the most important thing, that questioning the faith in any way was a crime, and that all the stuff that sounds crazy is a “mystery”. They labored to ensnare young and unformed minds. They worked desperately from the beginning to crush the merest thought about other gods and other faiths – monotheism has a strong undercurrent of cowardice in it, a stark terror that the faithful could ever be exposed to other religions and other gods. And they labored for centuries to prevent religious texts from being translated into vernacular dialects so that the common man could read God’s words for himself, without the priest’s help.
Listen to their sales pitch:
“Hello, you don’t know me, but from the minute you were born, you were condemned to spend all eternity in flames. You are responsible for the sin of Adam and for the crucifixion even though they happened long before you were born. Everyone is guilty no matter what, so we own you no matter what. But listen to everything we say with any questions, and give us money every week, and you’ll go to a really nice place when you die. You want proof? See, there ya go with the questions! It’s a mystery. Sorry, ya gotta buy the whole package: God, the devil, heaven, hell, creation, miracles....Here’s another: this bread and wine will change to human flesh and blood by magic, and then you’re going to eat it. Here’s another: this is a bone belonging to one of our greatest members – pray to it and your prayer will come true....Hey, we’re flexible people! It only took us a couple of centuries to admit that man is an animal and the earth is a satellite!”
As Christopher Hitchens pointed out in “God Is Not Great”, the notion that God is not only infallible but also the designer of everything doesn’t really hold water. The universe is a disordered mess, in our own solar system life cannot be sustained on eight of the nine planets, or on much of the earth’s surface either, and the sun is destined to explode and kill everything eventually. Ninety-eight percent of “God’s” species have died out.
Likewise his finest creation, the human body. Right after it’s born, God insists we cut off the foreskin – did he make a mistake? Did he really think things through when he added appendices, tonsils, vestigial tails, male nipples, body odor, halitosis, baldness, wrinkles, blindness, deafness, haemorrhoids, warts, a dozen baby illnesses like colic...? And I know women were supposed to be God’s afterthought, but seriously – he had to give them menstruation, PMS, menopause, and put the clitoris in completely the wrong place? A little joke on the girls? Oh, yeah, and childbirth, which speaks for itself.
Let’s take a moment to embrace the delusion of religion, here.
“God is my special, magical, invisible friend. He can do anything, but you can't see it. Of all the trillions of creatures in the world, he knows he, he loves me, and that makes me better than you. When I do something bad, he washes it away. And he will make me live forever, even after I die, although you won't see that either. He's magic!”
You see how stupid it sounds, stripped of all the mumbo jumbo? If my eight-year-old came to me with a story like that, I'd make her scrub toilets until she came to her senses.
God is the guy who told Bush to invade Iraq.God is the guy who told the Yorkshire Ripper to murder women. God is the guy who told David Koresh to kill 70 people. God told Pat Robertson, a presidential candidate who wanted his finger on the nuclear trigger, to prepare for the End of Days and the destruction of the world. God is the guy who talks to crazy people through the Tin Foil network.
Crack open your Bible, and read it as though it was a script for a play. The first three speaking characters are a supernatural being (Jehovah), a manufactured man (Adam), and...a talking snake. I mean, seriously.
Thomas Paine in “The Age of Reason” ridicules the logic of the testaments: “Having thus made an insurrection and a battle in heaven, in which none of the combatants could be either killed or wounded, put Satan in the pit, let him out again, given him a triumph over the whole creation, damned all mankind by the eating of an apple, there Christian mythologists bring the two ends of their fable together. They represent this virtuous and amiable man, Jesus Christ, to be at once both God and man, and also the son of God celestially begotten, on purpose to be sacrificed, because they say that Eve in her longing had eaten an apple.”
The silliness of Christian logic intensifies the closer you get to the linchpin of their entire reason for being, Jesus’ death and resurrection. If Christ had to die, why not disease, old age...? And if he had to die for our sins, why did he bounce right back out of the tomb two days later? Wouldn’t his sacrifice actually mean something if he actually, you know, sacrificed his life? If the cosmos is filled with inhabited worlds, does that mean Jesus had to go from world to world to world, dying in one after the other, over and over? And why is it that the people directly descended from the inhabitants of Jerusalem, the Jews, are the ones who insist that Jesus didn’t magically rise from the dead and fly into heaven a month later?
Paine again, on the alleged rising of saints from their graves at the crucifixion: “It is an easy thing to tell a lie, but it is difficult to support the lie after it is told. The writer of the book of Matthew should have told us who the saints were that came to life again, and went into the city, and what became of them afterward, and who it was that saw them — for he is not hardy enough to say he saw them himself; whether they came out naked, and all in natural buff, he-saints and she-saints; or whether they came full dressed, and where they got their dresses; whether they went to their former habitations, and reclaimed their wives, their husbands, and their property, and how they were received; whether they entered ejectments for the recovery of their possessions, or brought actions of crim. con. against the rival interlopers; whether they remained on earth, and followed their former occupation of preaching or working; or whether they died again, or went back to their graves alive, and buried themselves.”
When the priests of yore wrote the Bible, they were trying to take advantage of man’s limitless ignorance, to try to explain virtually the entire known universe: the origin of the world, and birth and enumeration of the Jewish people, the laws governing daily life, the rules for food, the rules for cleanliness, the rules for sex, the rules for worshipping God, the works. But whenever science catches up to religion, religion loses: geology has shown that hell ain’t down there and that the story of creation is dead wrong; archaeology proved that man descended from apes. Fifty years of astronauts have shown that the earth revolves around the sun and that God and heaven ain’t up there; nothing but space dust, broken satellites, and Buzz Aldrin’s golf balls.
Science disproves heaven, hell, and now the soul....Advances in neuroscience are pinpointing the brain functions which correspond to what we would have called the “soul” in less enlightened times. Our individuality and personality, our loves and hates, our morals and spirituality, all correlate to brain function. Scientists have proved not only that these functions are indivisible from the chemical processes in particular parts of the brain, but that drugs can alter them. The brain processes are the physical basis for all aspects of the “soul”, and they all stop when we die, so the notion of a soul surviving the body and going on to heaven in rubbish. This is an even greater challenge to religion than evolution. This is why some theologians are taking the easy way out – rejecting the scientific results. Too much truthiness.
If the God team got all that wrong, why should we believe the other obvious nonsense like the resurrection? The concept of God is like man’s appendix: in an earlier age it might have had a purpose, but now it’s merely dangerous. And Iron Age artefact, like cannibalism, slavery, human sacrifice, torture and war.
When human logic blows holes in the theist's argument for God, the theist simply redefines the term. "No, what I really meant by 'God' is...". Some post-medieval theists even went a step further, insisting that anything that man and science cannot explain -- or explain yet -- automatically belongs to God. As though the theists are simply using "God" as a big box in which we can dump everything that we don't understand. That's like defining God as a big filing cabinet which we use to organize our own ignorance.
A close reading of the Bible and subsequent religious history shows organized religion to be, in reality, a colossal fraud aimed at generating revenue. The Torah dispenses with God’s commandments in a couple of paragraphs, but then spends endless chapters describing the massive pile of offerings which the faithful must give to the priests to support their lavish lifestyle. And it’s been that way ever since.
It was this greed which finally killed the golden goose: one greedy cleric, the Archbishop of Mainz, wanted to hog two bishoprics for their revenue, while another, the Pope, want a ton of money for Saint Peters. So the Pope gave the archbishop his bishoprics if the archbishop, in return, agreed to raise the money for his church. The archbishop hired a bunco artist named John Tetzel to raise the money, and Tetzel started the indulgence circus, complete with sales jingles to separate the suckers from their money like PT Barnum. Then Luther heard about it and the real trouble began.
Unsurprisingly, Christianity has been clinically linked to weak intellectual actuity: Mensa reported that 39 different studies correlated religious belief, and lower intelligence and education – because evangelical Christianity demands that you swallow a gigantic pack of lies. The reason they target children is obvious: no sane adult would swallow their nonsense.
If you read the Bible from the beginning, as a mere work of literature, you find immediately that the most interesting character is…Jehovah. This character is childish, cruel, capricious, jealous and emotionally insecure, constantly demanding love and attention, imposing impossible demands, and throwing appalling tantrums when he doesn’t get his way. He’s Scarlett O’Hara with a taste for mass murder.
Only people who are truly gullible could possibly stick with this “God”.
The guys who claimed to be God’s spokesmen, Moses and Aaron, said that God made a promise to his people in the Old Testament. God then allowed his people to be thrown out of the allegedly “promised land” by unbelievers, driven into exile and slavery by Egyptians, Assyrians, Babylonians and Persians, overrun by Romans, chased all over Europe for 2000 years, and exterminated in the millions by Hitler. The middle third of the Bible – a full third of the book – is loaded with references to Jehovah’s decision to break his word and throw the Jews out of Israel, and send them off to Babylon – and all along the way, the Israelites insist that they deserved it.
The Jews who obeyed the Torah got hosed. Pagan idolators who did everything imaginable to break God's laws, like the Romans, the Huns, the Goths, and then the feudal lords of the Middle Ages -- they got to conquer the world. A little practical joke on the "chosen people"? Like Tevye the dairyman said -- yeah, Lord, I know we're the Chosen People, but could you choose someone else for a change? And God’s people stuck with him.
The greatest empire of all, Rome, swears loyalty to your God, under Constantine. Instead of looking after his people, God allows the empire to collapse into a century of civil war and then destruction by hordes of pagans who ain’t never heard of your God. And God’s people stuck with him.
Your religious leaders were caught in one sexual peccadillo after another. Bakker, Swaggart...And you stuck with them.
Listen to their sales pitch:
“Hello, you don’t know me, but from the minute you were born, you were condemned to spend all eternity in flames. You are responsible for the sin of Adam and for the crucifixion even though they happened long before you were born. Everyone is guilty no matter what, so we own you no matter what. But listen to everything we say with any questions, and give us money every week, and you’ll go to a really nice place when you die. You want proof? See, there ya go with the questions! It’s a mystery. Sorry, ya gotta buy the whole package: God, the devil, heaven, hell, creation, miracles....Here’s another: this bread and wine will change to human flesh and blood by magic, and then you’re going to eat it. Here’s another: this is a bone belonging to one of our greatest members – pray to it and your prayer will come true....Hey, we’re flexible people! It only took us a couple of centuries to admit that man is an animal and the earth is a satellite!”
As Christopher Hitchens pointed out in “God Is Not Great”, the notion that God is not only infallible but also the designer of everything doesn’t really hold water. The universe is a disordered mess, in our own solar system life cannot be sustained on eight of the nine planets, or on much of the earth’s surface either, and the sun is destined to explode and kill everything eventually. Ninety-eight percent of “God’s” species have died out.
Likewise his finest creation, the human body. Right after it’s born, God insists we cut off the foreskin – did he make a mistake? Did he really think things through when he added appendices, tonsils, vestigial tails, male nipples, body odor, halitosis, baldness, wrinkles, blindness, deafness, haemorrhoids, warts, a dozen baby illnesses like colic...? And I know women were supposed to be God’s afterthought, but seriously – he had to give them menstruation, PMS, menopause, and put the clitoris in completely the wrong place? A little joke on the girls? Oh, yeah, and childbirth, which speaks for itself.
Let’s take a moment to embrace the delusion of religion, here.
“God is my special, magical, invisible friend. He can do anything, but you can't see it. Of all the trillions of creatures in the world, he knows he, he loves me, and that makes me better than you. When I do something bad, he washes it away. And he will make me live forever, even after I die, although you won't see that either. He's magic!”
You see how stupid it sounds, stripped of all the mumbo jumbo? If my eight-year-old came to me with a story like that, I'd make her scrub toilets until she came to her senses.
God is the guy who told Bush to invade Iraq.God is the guy who told the Yorkshire Ripper to murder women. God is the guy who told David Koresh to kill 70 people. God told Pat Robertson, a presidential candidate who wanted his finger on the nuclear trigger, to prepare for the End of Days and the destruction of the world. God is the guy who talks to crazy people through the Tin Foil network.Crack open your Bible, and read it as though it was a script for a play. The first three speaking characters are a supernatural being (Jehovah), a manufactured man (Adam), and...a talking snake. I mean, seriously.
Thomas Paine in “The Age of Reason” ridicules the logic of the testaments: “Having thus made an insurrection and a battle in heaven, in which none of the combatants could be either killed or wounded, put Satan in the pit, let him out again, given him a triumph over the whole creation, damned all mankind by the eating of an apple, there Christian mythologists bring the two ends of their fable together. They represent this virtuous and amiable man, Jesus Christ, to be at once both God and man, and also the son of God celestially begotten, on purpose to be sacrificed, because they say that Eve in her longing had eaten an apple.”
The silliness of Christian logic intensifies the closer you get to the linchpin of their entire reason for being, Jesus’ death and resurrection. If Christ had to die, why not disease, old age...? And if he had to die for our sins, why did he bounce right back out of the tomb two days later? Wouldn’t his sacrifice actually mean something if he actually, you know, sacrificed his life? If the cosmos is filled with inhabited worlds, does that mean Jesus had to go from world to world to world, dying in one after the other, over and over? And why is it that the people directly descended from the inhabitants of Jerusalem, the Jews, are the ones who insist that Jesus didn’t magically rise from the dead and fly into heaven a month later?
Paine again, on the alleged rising of saints from their graves at the crucifixion: “It is an easy thing to tell a lie, but it is difficult to support the lie after it is told. The writer of the book of Matthew should have told us who the saints were that came to life again, and went into the city, and what became of them afterward, and who it was that saw them — for he is not hardy enough to say he saw them himself; whether they came out naked, and all in natural buff, he-saints and she-saints; or whether they came full dressed, and where they got their dresses; whether they went to their former habitations, and reclaimed their wives, their husbands, and their property, and how they were received; whether they entered ejectments for the recovery of their possessions, or brought actions of crim. con. against the rival interlopers; whether they remained on earth, and followed their former occupation of preaching or working; or whether they died again, or went back to their graves alive, and buried themselves.”
When the priests of yore wrote the Bible, they were trying to take advantage of man’s limitless ignorance, to try to explain virtually the entire known universe: the origin of the world, and birth and enumeration of the Jewish people, the laws governing daily life, the rules for food, the rules for cleanliness, the rules for sex, the rules for worshipping God, the works. But whenever science catches up to religion, religion loses: geology has shown that hell ain’t down there and that the story of creation is dead wrong; archaeology proved that man descended from apes. Fifty years of astronauts have shown that the earth revolves around the sun and that God and heaven ain’t up there; nothing but space dust, broken satellites, and Buzz Aldrin’s golf balls.Science disproves heaven, hell, and now the soul....Advances in neuroscience are pinpointing the brain functions which correspond to what we would have called the “soul” in less enlightened times. Our individuality and personality, our loves and hates, our morals and spirituality, all correlate to brain function. Scientists have proved not only that these functions are indivisible from the chemical processes in particular parts of the brain, but that drugs can alter them. The brain processes are the physical basis for all aspects of the “soul”, and they all stop when we die, so the notion of a soul surviving the body and going on to heaven in rubbish. This is an even greater challenge to religion than evolution. This is why some theologians are taking the easy way out – rejecting the scientific results. Too much truthiness.
If the God team got all that wrong, why should we believe the other obvious nonsense like the resurrection? The concept of God is like man’s appendix: in an earlier age it might have had a purpose, but now it’s merely dangerous. And Iron Age artefact, like cannibalism, slavery, human sacrifice, torture and war.
When human logic blows holes in the theist's argument for God, the theist simply redefines the term. "No, what I really meant by 'God' is...". Some post-medieval theists even went a step further, insisting that anything that man and science cannot explain -- or explain yet -- automatically belongs to God. As though the theists are simply using "God" as a big box in which we can dump everything that we don't understand. That's like defining God as a big filing cabinet which we use to organize our own ignorance.
A close reading of the Bible and subsequent religious history shows organized religion to be, in reality, a colossal fraud aimed at generating revenue. The Torah dispenses with God’s commandments in a couple of paragraphs, but then spends endless chapters describing the massive pile of offerings which the faithful must give to the priests to support their lavish lifestyle. And it’s been that way ever since.
It was this greed which finally killed the golden goose: one greedy cleric, the Archbishop of Mainz, wanted to hog two bishoprics for their revenue, while another, the Pope, want a ton of money for Saint Peters. So the Pope gave the archbishop his bishoprics if the archbishop, in return, agreed to raise the money for his church. The archbishop hired a bunco artist named John Tetzel to raise the money, and Tetzel started the indulgence circus, complete with sales jingles to separate the suckers from their money like PT Barnum. Then Luther heard about it and the real trouble began.
Unsurprisingly, Christianity has been clinically linked to weak intellectual actuity: Mensa reported that 39 different studies correlated religious belief, and lower intelligence and education – because evangelical Christianity demands that you swallow a gigantic pack of lies. The reason they target children is obvious: no sane adult would swallow their nonsense.
If you read the Bible from the beginning, as a mere work of literature, you find immediately that the most interesting character is…Jehovah. This character is childish, cruel, capricious, jealous and emotionally insecure, constantly demanding love and attention, imposing impossible demands, and throwing appalling tantrums when he doesn’t get his way. He’s Scarlett O’Hara with a taste for mass murder.
Only people who are truly gullible could possibly stick with this “God”.
The guys who claimed to be God’s spokesmen, Moses and Aaron, said that God made a promise to his people in the Old Testament. God then allowed his people to be thrown out of the allegedly “promised land” by unbelievers, driven into exile and slavery by Egyptians, Assyrians, Babylonians and Persians, overrun by Romans, chased all over Europe for 2000 years, and exterminated in the millions by Hitler. The middle third of the Bible – a full third of the book – is loaded with references to Jehovah’s decision to break his word and throw the Jews out of Israel, and send them off to Babylon – and all along the way, the Israelites insist that they deserved it.
The Jews who obeyed the Torah got hosed. Pagan idolators who did everything imaginable to break God's laws, like the Romans, the Huns, the Goths, and then the feudal lords of the Middle Ages -- they got to conquer the world. A little practical joke on the "chosen people"? Like Tevye the dairyman said -- yeah, Lord, I know we're the Chosen People, but could you choose someone else for a change? And God’s people stuck with him.
The greatest empire of all, Rome, swears loyalty to your God, under Constantine. Instead of looking after his people, God allows the empire to collapse into a century of civil war and then destruction by hordes of pagans who ain’t never heard of your God. And God’s people stuck with him.
Let’s see, the Crusades. God’s self-appointed spokesmen told all Europe that God wanted the Holy Land in Christian hands, and that God would never allow you to lose if you led an army to retake it. Six or seven armies you sent there, and God abandoned you. You even led an “army” of thousands of children to their deaths. And God’s people still stuck with the Man Upstairs.
The Black Death. God sent a pestilence to destroy Europe. 50 million God-fearing Christians, a small army of priests, prayed to God for mercy, and were slaughtered anyway. And God’s people still stayed with the program.
For 50 years you had a pope in Rome and a pope in France, each insisting that he was infallible and the other was an imposter. A century later your popes indulged in such an appalling pattern of corruption and vice that the Protestant reformation was virtually inevitable. Yet again, rival churches, each claiming that only their church had the true link to the Almighty. Shortly thereafter, Spain’s inquisitors were killing in the thousands, and exterminating hundreds of thousands in the New World. And Gods people stayed with the team. Or, now, teams.
A guy named Galileo proved the Bible wrong; instead of admitting they were wrong, the men of your church threatened him with torture if he didn’t shut up. Later Darwin shot more holes in the Big Book, and explorers from Yuri Gagarin onward saw heaven firsthand, and there was no God there. And through it all, God’s people stuck to him.
God’s spokesmen claim to be the world’s moral authority. So...the Holocaust. Biggest moral issue of the last century. The world waited for the Pope to denounce the Holocaust. Nada....This was all while your priests were molesting generation after generation of altar boys and schoolchildren.
Your religious leaders were caught in one sexual peccadillo after another. Bakker, Swaggart...And you stuck with them. Oral Roberts capped his lifelong career of lies by claiming that if the God’s People didn’t give him eight million dollars, God would kill him. The God people not only believed him, but actually gave him the money.
Your religious leaders told you abortion was murder, and if you gave money to them and to the Republican party, it would be outlawed. You gave them hundreds of millions of dollars, and they never came close to banning abortion. And now they’re planning to hornswoggle you with yet another doomed holy war against gays.
So how many times does Lucy pull away the football and watch Charlie Brown fall on his ass, before Charlie Brown gets the message?
Wednesday, 22 April 2009
When will U.S. atheists come out of the closet?
Yesterday it was announced that an atheist is going to join BBC's religion board. This is bound to have an impact on religion-related programming across Britain.Here in the United States, however, atheists are still very much in the closet, accustomed to hiding during the thirty-year reign of terror by the U.S. evangelical movement.
Look at the polls, for example. When people talk to pollsters, they often lie. It has already been established that they lie about how often they vote, go to museums, go to symphonies and operas, give to charity, have sex, and use drugs. Often pollsters are reporting the self-image of American people, rather than how they really live.
This includes going to church. A number of national polls have consistently said that over 40 percent of Americans claim they go to church each week. But independent studies show that the figure is actually 21-26 percent. That, incidentally, is the size of the Republican party these days: currently they’re down to 25 percent of the country.
So, at least a third of religious people are liars and hypocrites. And since millions are lying about going to church, we can assume that many are also lying when they say they believe in God. And then of course there are all the people who claim to be religious, but admit that they don’t go to church. So some of them don’t really believe, either: when they say they’re Catholic, they’re really saying “my parents were Catholic and I got married there, but I haven’t been to Church since Monte Carlo night.”
Likewise we can assume that we have many, many political leaders who don’t believe in God.
But how many politicians are willing to say so publicly? One guy, Congressman Pete Stark. And he didn’t start his career that way – he didn’t reveal his “preference” until he was 75 years old and had already served 24 years in Congress, in a seat that is so safely Democratic that he beats his opponents by about 3 to 1. So that isn’t exactly high on the Nathan Hale Scale of Bravery. Bu he’s ahead of everybody else.
In our political world, being an atheist is more horrible than being gay (Barney Franks is out of the closet), or soliciting in a public toilet (Larry Craig), or patronizing prostitutes (Vitter), or killing someone in a car crash (Kennedy, or even Laura Bush), or using illegal drugs (our last three presidents), or molesting children (Foley), or not paying your taxes on time (seemingly half of Obama’s cabinet), or being a proven criminal (dozens of examples from Marion Barry to Ted Stevens). Recent polling says that more than half of America would never vote for an atheist presidential candidate; the number of people who are willing to vote for an atheist actually dropped from 49 percent to 37 percent. Attacking atheists is the one form of bigotry that apparently is still okay.
Name another minority of 15-30 million people, who have almost no voice in government. Blacks, Jews, Mexicans...? Nope. The closest example is our 3 million Native Americans, but even they get land, casinos, an entire bureau of the Interior Department to take care of them, and the occasional politician.
And it doesn’t seem to bother anybody that this one minority, the atheists, has no voice.
For 30 years, meanwhile, our political discourse has been dominated by the three pillars of Republican arch-conservatism, and two of them have a strong under-current of evangelical stupidity: the ethos of the god-guns-gays culture warrior, and the messianic, God-told-Bush-to-invade-Iraq Crusader lunacy of the neocons. It is only because of the donations to the Republican party from religious loons, and their obnoxious insistence on ramming their views down our throats, that we have spend so much time arguing about their cherished issues.
Look at how much time we have wasted arguing about abortion, school vouchers, school prayer, intelligent design, putting the Commandments in courtrooms, stem cell research, euthanasia, cloning, civil unions, HPV shots, contraception, sex education, faith-based initiatives, banning books, assisted suicide....As though we don’t have more serious issues to discuss, like two wars, a dying industrial base, and a Depression. Not only do the evangelicals own the Republican agenda, even Democrats feel the need to kowtow to them.
Just imagine, if the evangelicals had not been so powerful, and we had spent the last 30 years thoroughly debating, not the abortion issue, but the health care issue, for example, or the issue of defense spending. Just think how much more informed our electorate would be right now on the issues that really matter.
For 30 years, the voices of religion – fear, hate, illusion, intolerance and wilful ignorance – have dominated our political life. As for the voices of atheism – logic, reason and tolerance – not only are they being ignored, but no one even acknowledges their existence. If you asked one of our political leaders what they think of atheists and their views, you would get a blank stare, and some serious stammering and backpedalling.
Atheists potentially have more to offer America than any group. Philosophy and politics cannot work without clear thought, logic, and a resistance to fallacy, and atheists play that game better than anyone out there. And the tide is turning: virtually everything religious people believe – from the pseudoscience of Genesis, to the absurdity of heaven and hell and the resurrection and other miracles, to the rigid and intolerant moral views on everything from gays to genocide to slavery – is slowly being exposed as fallacy.
So when do the grownups get their turn? And when can we have an actual atheist political leader who isn’t 77 years old?
The thing is, we already have atheists among our political leaders. We just need them to come out, the way Stark did.
Come out and lead! If the evangelicals can launch a 30-year revolution of suicidal folly, we can do the same, and save the country!
Religion has had a 3000-year head start, and has had nothing useful to say for centuries, whereas atheism as a movement has barely begun. What happens when we can finally use the truth to counteract the centuries of religious lies? Already the third largest U.S. religious group, behind Catholic and Baptist, is “none”. Twice as many Americans have great confidence in science, as in religion. Could reason kill religion for good in 100 years?
Look at the polls, for example. When people talk to pollsters, they often lie. It has already been established that they lie about how often they vote, go to museums, go to symphonies and operas, give to charity, have sex, and use drugs. Often pollsters are reporting the self-image of American people, rather than how they really live.
This includes going to church. A number of national polls have consistently said that over 40 percent of Americans claim they go to church each week. But independent studies show that the figure is actually 21-26 percent. That, incidentally, is the size of the Republican party these days: currently they’re down to 25 percent of the country.
So, at least a third of religious people are liars and hypocrites. And since millions are lying about going to church, we can assume that many are also lying when they say they believe in God. And then of course there are all the people who claim to be religious, but admit that they don’t go to church. So some of them don’t really believe, either: when they say they’re Catholic, they’re really saying “my parents were Catholic and I got married there, but I haven’t been to Church since Monte Carlo night.”
Likewise we can assume that we have many, many political leaders who don’t believe in God.
But how many politicians are willing to say so publicly? One guy, Congressman Pete Stark. And he didn’t start his career that way – he didn’t reveal his “preference” until he was 75 years old and had already served 24 years in Congress, in a seat that is so safely Democratic that he beats his opponents by about 3 to 1. So that isn’t exactly high on the Nathan Hale Scale of Bravery. Bu he’s ahead of everybody else.
In our political world, being an atheist is more horrible than being gay (Barney Franks is out of the closet), or soliciting in a public toilet (Larry Craig), or patronizing prostitutes (Vitter), or killing someone in a car crash (Kennedy, or even Laura Bush), or using illegal drugs (our last three presidents), or molesting children (Foley), or not paying your taxes on time (seemingly half of Obama’s cabinet), or being a proven criminal (dozens of examples from Marion Barry to Ted Stevens). Recent polling says that more than half of America would never vote for an atheist presidential candidate; the number of people who are willing to vote for an atheist actually dropped from 49 percent to 37 percent. Attacking atheists is the one form of bigotry that apparently is still okay.
Name another minority of 15-30 million people, who have almost no voice in government. Blacks, Jews, Mexicans...? Nope. The closest example is our 3 million Native Americans, but even they get land, casinos, an entire bureau of the Interior Department to take care of them, and the occasional politician.
And it doesn’t seem to bother anybody that this one minority, the atheists, has no voice.
For 30 years, meanwhile, our political discourse has been dominated by the three pillars of Republican arch-conservatism, and two of them have a strong under-current of evangelical stupidity: the ethos of the god-guns-gays culture warrior, and the messianic, God-told-Bush-to-invade-Iraq Crusader lunacy of the neocons. It is only because of the donations to the Republican party from religious loons, and their obnoxious insistence on ramming their views down our throats, that we have spend so much time arguing about their cherished issues.
Look at how much time we have wasted arguing about abortion, school vouchers, school prayer, intelligent design, putting the Commandments in courtrooms, stem cell research, euthanasia, cloning, civil unions, HPV shots, contraception, sex education, faith-based initiatives, banning books, assisted suicide....As though we don’t have more serious issues to discuss, like two wars, a dying industrial base, and a Depression. Not only do the evangelicals own the Republican agenda, even Democrats feel the need to kowtow to them.
Just imagine, if the evangelicals had not been so powerful, and we had spent the last 30 years thoroughly debating, not the abortion issue, but the health care issue, for example, or the issue of defense spending. Just think how much more informed our electorate would be right now on the issues that really matter.
For 30 years, the voices of religion – fear, hate, illusion, intolerance and wilful ignorance – have dominated our political life. As for the voices of atheism – logic, reason and tolerance – not only are they being ignored, but no one even acknowledges their existence. If you asked one of our political leaders what they think of atheists and their views, you would get a blank stare, and some serious stammering and backpedalling.
Atheists potentially have more to offer America than any group. Philosophy and politics cannot work without clear thought, logic, and a resistance to fallacy, and atheists play that game better than anyone out there. And the tide is turning: virtually everything religious people believe – from the pseudoscience of Genesis, to the absurdity of heaven and hell and the resurrection and other miracles, to the rigid and intolerant moral views on everything from gays to genocide to slavery – is slowly being exposed as fallacy.
So when do the grownups get their turn? And when can we have an actual atheist political leader who isn’t 77 years old?
The thing is, we already have atheists among our political leaders. We just need them to come out, the way Stark did.
Come out and lead! If the evangelicals can launch a 30-year revolution of suicidal folly, we can do the same, and save the country!
Religion has had a 3000-year head start, and has had nothing useful to say for centuries, whereas atheism as a movement has barely begun. What happens when we can finally use the truth to counteract the centuries of religious lies? Already the third largest U.S. religious group, behind Catholic and Baptist, is “none”. Twice as many Americans have great confidence in science, as in religion. Could reason kill religion for good in 100 years?
The Bible is the word of...who? Not God.
The Church of Scotland said something sensible Monday: "Every student of the Bible is a selective literalist. Those who swear by the anti-homosexual laws in the Book of Leviticus wouldn't publicly advocate slavery or stoning women taken in adultery. They presumably no longer accept Biblical teaching on sexual matters such as polygamy and sex with slaves. And yet there are many who continue to be bound by a few Biblical verses - none of them in the Gospels - about homosexuality, nowadays understood as a matter of genetics rather than lifestyle."But let's look at the larger question: where did the Bible really come from?
The evangelicals insist that the Bible is the unchallengeable word of God, as passed directly to the prophets. The problem is that no one knows where these texts really came from.
As Thomas Paine pointed out, the Bible is allegedly based on the word of God, divine revelation to man. But it is only a revelation to that man – everything after that is hearsay. Bush claims God told him to invade Iraq; Peter Sutcliffe, the Yorkshire Ripper, claims God told him to kill women. This is why you can’t rely on hearsay.
And much of the Bible cannot be claimed as revelation of any kind, even the second-hand variety. When the Bible reports observable historical events, that is not divine revelation – that wipes out the Old Testament histories, the Gospels, and Acts. The Bible’s songs are not divine revelation either, or the proverbs, or the letters, or the lamentations. So right away, most of the Bible is not the word of God.
A number of biblical references seem to indicate that the “prophets” were poets or musicians.
This stuff in the Bible started as oral and then written fragments, and no one knows who created them. Religious scholars have concluded that every book of the Bible may have been written by more than one person – so can a burning bush “reveal” to two people at once? No one can say within 500 years when the Torah was written. Even Jewish leaders argue about whether Moses wrote the Pentateuch, particularly since it refers to Moses in the third person and discusses Moses’ death; by the 17th century, scholars essentially proved that Moses could not have written the Pentateuch, although the Church tried to suppress these facts. The Book of Ruth was probably “written” by someone who wasn’t even Jewish. Judges is anonymous – you can’t have God revealing his word to someone we don’t even know. Samuel couldn’t have written the book attributed to him since it describes his death; Isaiah was also written after Isaiah was dead.
The first three gospels – the “synoptic” gospels – were based in part on a mysterious “Q” document. No version of it exists and no one knows who wrote it, let alone who or what inspired it. Scholars are still arguing about which gospels stole from each other and which passages were written first. Much of the material seems to have been assembled from tiny fragments of scripture, and none of the material is first-hand from anybody, let alone God. Mark and Luke were not present for the events they reported, and we don’t know where they got their information from, other than the Q, which the Almighty, with suspicious carelessness, managed to lose for all time. Of all the epistles of Paul, only seven are deemed with any confidence to be Paul’s actual work; as for the rest – no one knows for sure who wrote them. The authorship of all John’s books is in dispute, particularly since some geographical errors in his alleged works suggest he was not from Palestine; on the other hand they could have been written by Mary Magdalene. And many of these texts may be corrupted by the extensive use of scribes by illiterate or semi-literate religious leaders.
If God wanted to make his will known to all nations, he wouldn’t choose a poor carpenter in a despised ethnic group in a distant corner of the Roman empire.
The evangelicals insist that the Bible is the unchallengeable word of God, as passed directly to the prophets. The problem is that no one knows where these texts really came from.
As Thomas Paine pointed out, the Bible is allegedly based on the word of God, divine revelation to man. But it is only a revelation to that man – everything after that is hearsay. Bush claims God told him to invade Iraq; Peter Sutcliffe, the Yorkshire Ripper, claims God told him to kill women. This is why you can’t rely on hearsay.
And much of the Bible cannot be claimed as revelation of any kind, even the second-hand variety. When the Bible reports observable historical events, that is not divine revelation – that wipes out the Old Testament histories, the Gospels, and Acts. The Bible’s songs are not divine revelation either, or the proverbs, or the letters, or the lamentations. So right away, most of the Bible is not the word of God.
A number of biblical references seem to indicate that the “prophets” were poets or musicians.
This stuff in the Bible started as oral and then written fragments, and no one knows who created them. Religious scholars have concluded that every book of the Bible may have been written by more than one person – so can a burning bush “reveal” to two people at once? No one can say within 500 years when the Torah was written. Even Jewish leaders argue about whether Moses wrote the Pentateuch, particularly since it refers to Moses in the third person and discusses Moses’ death; by the 17th century, scholars essentially proved that Moses could not have written the Pentateuch, although the Church tried to suppress these facts. The Book of Ruth was probably “written” by someone who wasn’t even Jewish. Judges is anonymous – you can’t have God revealing his word to someone we don’t even know. Samuel couldn’t have written the book attributed to him since it describes his death; Isaiah was also written after Isaiah was dead.
The first three gospels – the “synoptic” gospels – were based in part on a mysterious “Q” document. No version of it exists and no one knows who wrote it, let alone who or what inspired it. Scholars are still arguing about which gospels stole from each other and which passages were written first. Much of the material seems to have been assembled from tiny fragments of scripture, and none of the material is first-hand from anybody, let alone God. Mark and Luke were not present for the events they reported, and we don’t know where they got their information from, other than the Q, which the Almighty, with suspicious carelessness, managed to lose for all time. Of all the epistles of Paul, only seven are deemed with any confidence to be Paul’s actual work; as for the rest – no one knows for sure who wrote them. The authorship of all John’s books is in dispute, particularly since some geographical errors in his alleged works suggest he was not from Palestine; on the other hand they could have been written by Mary Magdalene. And many of these texts may be corrupted by the extensive use of scribes by illiterate or semi-literate religious leaders.
If God wanted to make his will known to all nations, he wouldn’t choose a poor carpenter in a despised ethnic group in a distant corner of the Roman empire.
So....What does the Bible really say?
A problem with the Bible is that the text is widely open to interpretation, and therefore cannot be the unchallengeable word of God. During the first two centuries of the Christian era, the beliefs of the various Christian groups varied wildly – they couldn’t all have been right. Also during the first few centuries of the Christian era, many different versions of the “word of God” were bouncing around the Mediterranean.
Four hundred years ago, a team of English scholars tried to bring order to the chaos, and worked endlessly to argue about interpretations and translations of the ancient texts. The purpose was to create a text that conformed to the views of the King of England. Forty-seven men argued and argued as to what the word of God meant. In the end they had to reach an agreement on what the word of God was. The result: the King James Bible, all a matter of opinion and interpretation. Since the King James Bible has passed out of copyright, anyone can print their own version – and alter it if they choose.
Keep in mind that the authors of the King James made little effort to study the original ancient manuscripts first-hand. The revered King James New Testament relies for 90 percent of its text on the Tyndale Bible, written by a man who didn’t even have access to the ancient texts. So essentially you have interpretations of interpretations.
Yet another problem: over the centuries the “unchallengeable” word of God has been loaded with errors. The ancient oral versions and the early handwritten manuscripts – errors everywhere. The early Bibles contained explanatory words, prefaces, pictures and other bits which clearly were not the “word of God”. In many cases, scribes from early periods wrote commentaries in the margins of their texts, which later scribes included in the actual text, because they weren’t sure whether they were text or just marginal notes; in this way, marginal scribbling became the “word of God”. During early printing efforts in the 16th and 17th centuries, texts were changed at whim, sometimes by printer/editors who wanted to remain anonymous. Quality control was notoriously bad, as typified by the 1631 “thou shalt commit adultery” Bible. 150 years after the King James version, there were so many corrupted versions that the English Church had to go back and clean it all up with new versions; thousands of changes were made.
And a key dealbreaker on this point is the many contradictions within the Bible itself: the same story told in different ways. The Gospels alone contradict themselves and each other on Jesus’ lineage, crucifixion and resurrection; Kings, Chronicles and Jeremiah pose the same problems. If the Book challenges itself, why can’t we challenge it too? Religious leaders will argue either that (a) the contradictions are God’s mystery, or (b) only a truly “inspired” reader can see the contradictions for what they really are, “counterpoints”. Oh, bull.
The Bible also collides with proven fact in many places as well, and not just in the fractured science of Genesis. Luke had the wrong governor of Syria for the time of Jesus’ birth; the records of Josephus and the Romans show that there was no census at that time, and that when they did conduct a census they did no require that families return to their birthplaces.
The written Torah is often incomprehensible without an oral tradition which divides texts into sentences and puts vowels on words, which can change the meaning in Hebrew. Jews are still arguing as to whether that is acceptable, and whether the result is actually the word of God. You could reasonably argue that the consonants are the word of God, but the vowels aren’t. By the same token, originally the New Testament didn’t even have punctuated sentences, leaving even more room for interpretation and error.
The next problem: teams of translators (and other interpreters) have been changing the meaning of the word of God for 3000 years. The Bible, or parts thereof, has been translated into hundreds of languages, and the word of God varies from language to language. Some translations cater to prejudice, like changing the “he’s” to “he/she’s” etc. Even today, religious leaders argue over whether literal or idiomatic translations are preferable.
Over the centuries, hundreds of people had a hand in creating or altering the alleged word of God, and we have almost no information on who these people were.
Human language has never been universal and has been constantly changing in meaning. How could a God possibly use it to express his will?
The first Biblical texts were written in Hebrew, but they were written for people who spoke Aramaic and didn’t understand Hebrew, so even in the early days, the Bible was in a language which its adherents couldn’t understand, just as Christians had to put up with a Latin Bible for hundreds of years, and a Latin mass for even longer. The word of God was overwhelmingly delivered in a foreign tongue to the locals. By the same token, the famous Douai Bible is based on translations of translations, which greatly increases the number of errors.
Human choice determines the word of God.
Christians can’t even agree on what the “unchallengeable word of God” even means. Some follow the doctrine of inerrancy, which means that the whole Bible is accurate, even on history and science; the second doctrine, infallibility, merely asserts that the Bible is accurate only on faith and practice. Christians are still arguing about which is true. A third school, the “authoritativeness” school, says the Bible is accurate on issues of morality. Likewise, even Conservative Jews have four ways in which they interpret the divinity of the word of God.
To make matters worse, all of this interpretation has been tangled up in human political issues. Medieval Christian leaders discouraged translations of the Old Testament for political reasons. Pope Innocent III banned unauthorized translations – people who tried to reach out and understand the word of God were punished (rather like Adam and Eve at the tree of knowledge). Likewise Henry VIII suppressed the circulation of English-language Bibles; Henry changed his mind and tried to make the Bible available to the people, but then changed his mind again and decreed that only the upper classes could have it. Mary I, his daughter, also suppressed the circulation of Bibles. During the early days of the Reformation many competing versions of the Bible were in circulation, and the ones unpopular with the monarch of the day were burned.
Even the issue of which texts were, in fact, the word of God was argued over, by humans, from the beginning. For 600 years, Jewish leaders known as Masoretes argued about what should even BE in the text of the Bible. For 600 years there was no agreement on what the word of God even was. It is possible that ancient Jewish leaders decided which books to include as the “word of God” based on what the Christians put in their own Bible.
Things got worse when the Christians got involved. The Church didn’t even get everyone on the same page with regard to doctrine – let alone scripture – until the First Council of Nicaea in 325 AD. In the fourth century Christian leaders held a series of meetings to decide which texts were the word of God. The books of the New Testament were “canonized” – deemed holy – 300 years after Jesus and most of the other central players were dead. Originally the Book of Revelation was left out – and no wonder.
When the Protestant reformation came around, the arguments about which books were really the word of God started all over again. Different denominations now include different books: Catholic, Protestant, Orthodox, Slavonic. Different traditions include different books in the Bible as “God’s word”.
Protestants established four “criteria for canonicity”, to decide which scripture is “holy”. First, apostolic origin, which means it came from the disciples chosen by the church’s followers. Universal acceptance, which means the texts were chosen by the church’s followers. Liturgical use, which means that the church’s followers chose to use it in church. Consistent message, which means the text preaches a message which agrees with what is popular with the church’s followers. In other words, the divinity of the texts was a popularity contest among humans.
So what do we have here? No one knows where this stuff comes from. We don’t know when these fragments of oral storytelling were first jotted down, or by whom, but we know they were human beings. As the centuries rolled on, their successors (who had no part in the original “revelation”) added their own human translation abilities, their own human interpretations, their human political issues, and their many, many human errors. And these human beings have been arguing about what these texts mean, for centuries. They have even argued about which books should be included at all. And in the middle of all this, they have decreed that these texts (whichever ones they decide to include) were passed on centuries ago as the unchallengeable word of an unchallengeable God – and then they set about arguing about what “unchallengeable” means.
For my money, as soon as you have dozens of denominations and sects using dozens of different versions of the same book (which itself has four different versions of Jesus’ life), the whole “unchallengeable” notion goes out the window. As soon as you get to a point where you can simply use your own human impulses to choose which of these versions is the right one, you’ve lost “unchallengeability”. The fact that all those other versions even exist, is in itself a challenge to the book you choose.
And without the “unchallengeable” word of God, where do we get God from?
A problem with the Bible is that the text is widely open to interpretation, and therefore cannot be the unchallengeable word of God. During the first two centuries of the Christian era, the beliefs of the various Christian groups varied wildly – they couldn’t all have been right. Also during the first few centuries of the Christian era, many different versions of the “word of God” were bouncing around the Mediterranean.
Four hundred years ago, a team of English scholars tried to bring order to the chaos, and worked endlessly to argue about interpretations and translations of the ancient texts. The purpose was to create a text that conformed to the views of the King of England. Forty-seven men argued and argued as to what the word of God meant. In the end they had to reach an agreement on what the word of God was. The result: the King James Bible, all a matter of opinion and interpretation. Since the King James Bible has passed out of copyright, anyone can print their own version – and alter it if they choose.
Keep in mind that the authors of the King James made little effort to study the original ancient manuscripts first-hand. The revered King James New Testament relies for 90 percent of its text on the Tyndale Bible, written by a man who didn’t even have access to the ancient texts. So essentially you have interpretations of interpretations.
Yet another problem: over the centuries the “unchallengeable” word of God has been loaded with errors. The ancient oral versions and the early handwritten manuscripts – errors everywhere. The early Bibles contained explanatory words, prefaces, pictures and other bits which clearly were not the “word of God”. In many cases, scribes from early periods wrote commentaries in the margins of their texts, which later scribes included in the actual text, because they weren’t sure whether they were text or just marginal notes; in this way, marginal scribbling became the “word of God”. During early printing efforts in the 16th and 17th centuries, texts were changed at whim, sometimes by printer/editors who wanted to remain anonymous. Quality control was notoriously bad, as typified by the 1631 “thou shalt commit adultery” Bible. 150 years after the King James version, there were so many corrupted versions that the English Church had to go back and clean it all up with new versions; thousands of changes were made.
And a key dealbreaker on this point is the many contradictions within the Bible itself: the same story told in different ways. The Gospels alone contradict themselves and each other on Jesus’ lineage, crucifixion and resurrection; Kings, Chronicles and Jeremiah pose the same problems. If the Book challenges itself, why can’t we challenge it too? Religious leaders will argue either that (a) the contradictions are God’s mystery, or (b) only a truly “inspired” reader can see the contradictions for what they really are, “counterpoints”. Oh, bull.
The Bible also collides with proven fact in many places as well, and not just in the fractured science of Genesis. Luke had the wrong governor of Syria for the time of Jesus’ birth; the records of Josephus and the Romans show that there was no census at that time, and that when they did conduct a census they did no require that families return to their birthplaces.
The written Torah is often incomprehensible without an oral tradition which divides texts into sentences and puts vowels on words, which can change the meaning in Hebrew. Jews are still arguing as to whether that is acceptable, and whether the result is actually the word of God. You could reasonably argue that the consonants are the word of God, but the vowels aren’t. By the same token, originally the New Testament didn’t even have punctuated sentences, leaving even more room for interpretation and error.
The next problem: teams of translators (and other interpreters) have been changing the meaning of the word of God for 3000 years. The Bible, or parts thereof, has been translated into hundreds of languages, and the word of God varies from language to language. Some translations cater to prejudice, like changing the “he’s” to “he/she’s” etc. Even today, religious leaders argue over whether literal or idiomatic translations are preferable.
Over the centuries, hundreds of people had a hand in creating or altering the alleged word of God, and we have almost no information on who these people were.
Human language has never been universal and has been constantly changing in meaning. How could a God possibly use it to express his will?
The first Biblical texts were written in Hebrew, but they were written for people who spoke Aramaic and didn’t understand Hebrew, so even in the early days, the Bible was in a language which its adherents couldn’t understand, just as Christians had to put up with a Latin Bible for hundreds of years, and a Latin mass for even longer. The word of God was overwhelmingly delivered in a foreign tongue to the locals. By the same token, the famous Douai Bible is based on translations of translations, which greatly increases the number of errors.
Human choice determines the word of God.
Christians can’t even agree on what the “unchallengeable word of God” even means. Some follow the doctrine of inerrancy, which means that the whole Bible is accurate, even on history and science; the second doctrine, infallibility, merely asserts that the Bible is accurate only on faith and practice. Christians are still arguing about which is true. A third school, the “authoritativeness” school, says the Bible is accurate on issues of morality. Likewise, even Conservative Jews have four ways in which they interpret the divinity of the word of God.
To make matters worse, all of this interpretation has been tangled up in human political issues. Medieval Christian leaders discouraged translations of the Old Testament for political reasons. Pope Innocent III banned unauthorized translations – people who tried to reach out and understand the word of God were punished (rather like Adam and Eve at the tree of knowledge). Likewise Henry VIII suppressed the circulation of English-language Bibles; Henry changed his mind and tried to make the Bible available to the people, but then changed his mind again and decreed that only the upper classes could have it. Mary I, his daughter, also suppressed the circulation of Bibles. During the early days of the Reformation many competing versions of the Bible were in circulation, and the ones unpopular with the monarch of the day were burned.
Even the issue of which texts were, in fact, the word of God was argued over, by humans, from the beginning. For 600 years, Jewish leaders known as Masoretes argued about what should even BE in the text of the Bible. For 600 years there was no agreement on what the word of God even was. It is possible that ancient Jewish leaders decided which books to include as the “word of God” based on what the Christians put in their own Bible.
Things got worse when the Christians got involved. The Church didn’t even get everyone on the same page with regard to doctrine – let alone scripture – until the First Council of Nicaea in 325 AD. In the fourth century Christian leaders held a series of meetings to decide which texts were the word of God. The books of the New Testament were “canonized” – deemed holy – 300 years after Jesus and most of the other central players were dead. Originally the Book of Revelation was left out – and no wonder.
When the Protestant reformation came around, the arguments about which books were really the word of God started all over again. Different denominations now include different books: Catholic, Protestant, Orthodox, Slavonic. Different traditions include different books in the Bible as “God’s word”.
Protestants established four “criteria for canonicity”, to decide which scripture is “holy”. First, apostolic origin, which means it came from the disciples chosen by the church’s followers. Universal acceptance, which means the texts were chosen by the church’s followers. Liturgical use, which means that the church’s followers chose to use it in church. Consistent message, which means the text preaches a message which agrees with what is popular with the church’s followers. In other words, the divinity of the texts was a popularity contest among humans.
So what do we have here? No one knows where this stuff comes from. We don’t know when these fragments of oral storytelling were first jotted down, or by whom, but we know they were human beings. As the centuries rolled on, their successors (who had no part in the original “revelation”) added their own human translation abilities, their own human interpretations, their human political issues, and their many, many human errors. And these human beings have been arguing about what these texts mean, for centuries. They have even argued about which books should be included at all. And in the middle of all this, they have decreed that these texts (whichever ones they decide to include) were passed on centuries ago as the unchallengeable word of an unchallengeable God – and then they set about arguing about what “unchallengeable” means.
For my money, as soon as you have dozens of denominations and sects using dozens of different versions of the same book (which itself has four different versions of Jesus’ life), the whole “unchallengeable” notion goes out the window. As soon as you get to a point where you can simply use your own human impulses to choose which of these versions is the right one, you’ve lost “unchallengeability”. The fact that all those other versions even exist, is in itself a challenge to the book you choose.
And without the “unchallengeable” word of God, where do we get God from?
Tuesday, 14 April 2009
An evangelical meets James Madison
This summary is not available. Please
click here to view the post.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)